Discover Your Perfect Plum Island Vacation Homes

Best Vacation Homes in Plum Island

Why Choose Rent By Owner for your Plum Island Vacation Rental Homes?

What makes our Vacation Rentals special?

image
Verified Listings
Book with confidence knowing every property meets our quality and safety standards.
image
Unbeatable Value
Enjoy competitive pricing with no hidden fees, providing exceptional value for every stay.
image
Diverse Options
From cozy cabins to luxurious villas, find a rental that suits your style and needs.

Popular Areas for Plum Island Vacation Rentals

Where are the best neighborhoods to stay in Plum Island?

When planning your stay in Plum Island, Highlands, New Jersey, choosing the right neighborhood can enhance your vacation experience. The area offers a variety of charming and peaceful neighborhoods that provide easy access to the stunning shoreline and local amenities. Whether you're seeking a tranquil retreat or a lively community, the neighborhoods around Highlands are known for their welcoming atmosphere and scenic surroundings. Booking a vacation rental in this region ensures you enjoy both comfort and convenience, making your visit to Plum Island memorable and relaxing.

Queens

As part of the New York City metropolitan area, Queens offers easy access to diverse neighborhoods and cultural attractions, making it a convenient base for exploring the region's vibrant atmosphere.

View 996+ Rentals in Queens

Sandy Hook

Located near the region, Sandy Hook provides tranquil seaside surroundings and scenic views, perfect for relaxing stays and outdoor activities along the coast.

View 73+ Rentals in Sandy Hook

Brighton Beach

This lively neighborhood is renowned for its beautiful beachfront and diverse community, offering an authentic seaside experience close to the city's attractions.

View 97+ Rentals in Brighton Beach

Sheepshead Bay

Known for its picturesque waterfront, Sheepshead Bay is ideal for visitors seeking a peaceful harbor setting combined with easy access to local dining and entertainment options.

View 111+ Rentals in Sheepshead Bay

South Beach

South Beach features a relaxing shoreline environment, making it a popular choice for those wanting to enjoy the sun and sand just minutes from urban conveniences.

View 36+ Rentals in South Beach

Manhattan Beach

Offering stunning ocean views and a laid-back vibe, Manhattan Beach is an excellent spot for beach lovers looking to unwind while staying close to New York City's attractions.

View 105+ Rentals in Manhattan Beach

Belle Harbor

Situated along the coast, Belle Harbor combines scenic beauty with a close-knit community feel, ideal for visitors seeking a peaceful seaside retreat nearby urban amenities.

View 54+ Rentals in Belle Harbor

Port Monmouth

Nestled along the river, Port Monmouth offers tranquil waterside surroundings and a charming atmosphere, perfect for a relaxing stay in the region.

View 56+ Rentals in Port Monmouth

Best Times to Visit Plum Island

When should you plan your Vacation Rentals stay?

Choosing the optimal time to visit this charming coastal area can enhance your experience, as the region offers different attractions and atmospheres depending on the season, making it ideal to plan your stay in accordance with what you wish to enjoy during your getaway.

Peak Season Highlights

summer
Summer (June to August)

During the peak summer months, you can enjoy warm temperatures perfect for beach activities and outdoor exploration along the coast.

Average Temperature Daytime: 78°F to 85°F - Nighttime: 65°F to 70°F
autumn
Early Fall (September to October)

This is a popular time for visiting when the weather remains mild and the area offers a quieter atmosphere after the busy summer season.

Average Temperature Daytime: 70°F to 75°F - Nighttime: 58°F to 62°F

Off-Season Highlights

image
Late Fall to Early Winter (November to December)

As the region transitions into cooler weather, fewer visitors mean more tranquility, ideal for relaxing stays in rental properties.

Average Temperature Daytime: 50°F to 60°F - Nighttime: 40°F to 45°F
image
Winter (January to February)

You might experience colder days here, but off-peak winter visits often provide budget-friendly options and a peaceful environment.

Average Temperature Daytime: 40°F to 50°F - Nighttime: 30°F to 35°F

Weekly Weather Forecast for Plum Island

How to Book Your Plum Island Vacation Rental Home

What's our booking process?

Our platform allows you to browse a curated selection of vacation rentals. Once you find the ideal property, you’ll be redirected to a trusted booking partner to complete your reservation securely.

Booking Steps

01

Search Properties

Use our filters to find the right property that fits your needs.
02

Select a Rental

Click on your preferred listing to view details, amenities, and pricing.
03

Book Online

Follow the link to finalize your reservation directly on the partner’s website.

Explore and book the perfect rental in Plum Island

More Top-Rated Vacation Rentals in Plum Island Area

Common Vacation Rentals Amenities

What amenities can you expect?

Our Vacation Rentals are designed to offer all the comforts of home, often with added perks to make your stay unforgettable. Here’s some common amenities to look forward to:

Indoor Features

  • Fully-equipped kitchens with modern appliances
  • Comfortable living areas with flat-screen TVs
  • Free Wi-Fi for staying connected
  • Air conditioning and heating for year-round comfort
  • In-unit washers and dryers for convenience
  • Luxurious bedrooms with premium bedding
  • Spa-like bathrooms with soaking tubs or walk-in showers

Outdoor Amenities

  • Enjoy outdoor dining setups with picnic tables and grilling stations for gatherings in the fresh air.
  • Take advantage of private or shared outdoor decks and patios to relax while soaking in the coastal scenery.
  • Make the most of lush, landscaped yards ideal for outdoor activities or simply unwinding amidst nature.
  • Benefit from easy access to nearby beaches, perfect for sunbathing, swimming, or beachcombing.
  • Utilize outdoor shower facilities to rinse off after a day at the shore or outdoor adventures.
  • Participate in outdoor recreational features like fire pits or lounge areas, perfect for evening gatherings.
  • Leverage shaded outdoor spaces such as pergolas or awnings that provide comfort during sunny days in the region.

Top Attractions Around Plum Island

What attractions are nearby?

Nearby, you can enjoy activities such as scenic walks along the shoreline, exploring local parks, and indulging in fresh seafood at nearby waterfront eateries, making this destination perfect for relaxing outdoor adventures in the Highlands region.

image
image

Family Activities

  • Beachcombing and Sandcastle Building: Spend a day exploring the sandy shores where your family can enjoy collecting seashells and creating sandcastles along the picturesque coastline.
  • Seaside Wildlife Watching: Discover the region’s diverse bird species and local marine life on guided nature walks or from the comfort of your vacation rental’s nearby vantage points.
  • Kayaking and Paddleboarding: Engage in water activities suitable for all ages, offering an exciting way to explore the calm waters surrounding this scenic destination.
  • Local Maritime History Tours: Immerse your family in the area's rich maritime heritage with visits to informative historic sites and museums that bring the region's seafaring past to life.
image

Adult Activities

  • Bird Watching Tours: Experience the region's diverse avian population with guided bird watching excursions along here’s scenic coastal trails.
  • Kayaking Adventures: Explore the calm waters surrounding the area on a kayaking trip, providing a unique perspective of the region’s natural beauty.
  • Fishing Charters: Enjoy a day on the water with professional fishing charters that cater to enthusiasts seeking a relaxing or active day out.
  • Shopping at Local Boutiques: Discover charming local boutiques and shops nearby, perfect for finding unique souvenirs and enjoying a leisurely day in this destination.

Plum Island Travel Tips

How Can You Make the Most of Your Stay?

  • Explore Local Beaches: Take advantage of the pristine shoreline nearby to enjoy sunbathing, swimming, and beachcombing during your stay.
  • Visit Scenic Spots: Discover the area's natural beauty by visiting nearby parks or walking along scenic coastal trails for unforgettable views.
  • Savor Regional Cuisine: Indulge in fresh seafood and local delicacies at restaurants and eateries that capture the flavors of this destination.
  • Plan Water Activities: Make the most of your visit by engaging in kayaking, paddleboarding, or boat rentals available close to your vacation rental.

Transportation Options

  • Car Rentals: Renting a car provides the convenience and flexibility to explore Highlands and the surrounding areas at your own pace.
  • Public Transit: Local bus services connect you to key destinations, making it an affordable option for getting around this coastal region.
  • Taxi and Rideshare Services: Taxis and rideshare options like Uber or Lyft are readily available for quick and direct transportation here.
  • Bike Rentals: Biking is an excellent way to enjoy the scenic views and reach nearby beaches in the area comfortably.

Local Customs Options

  • Seafood Traditions: Locally inspired seafood customs are an integral part of the area's maritime culture, reflecting a deep connection to fresh catches from the nearby waters.
  • Beach Etiquette: Visitors often observe respectful beach manners, such as handling shellfish carefully and maintaining cleanliness, which are valued here for preserving the natural beauty.
  • Fishing Practices: The community has a long-standing tradition of responsible fishing, emphasizing sustainable techniques that support the region’s vibrant marine ecosystem.
  • Local Celebrations: Seasonal festivals celebrating coastal heritage showcase traditional music, dance, and artisanal crafts unique to this destination’s maritime history.

Frequently Asked Questions About Plum Island?

1. What are the top vacation rentals in Plum Island?

There are a lot of options in Plum Island. If you plan on staying in the Plum Island area, consider making a reservation for a few nights at one of these properties as these have been rated the Top Vacation Rentals in Plum Island:

2. How many Rentbyowner vacation rentals are available in Plum Island?

Currently, the total number of properties listed by Rent By Owner in 2025 is over 106 in the Plum Island area, and still counting. By aggregating listings from multiple websites, Rent By Owner offers an immense amount of choice of the best RBO properties in Plum Island. 

3. What is the cancellation policy for vacation rentals in this area?

Cancellation policies vary by listing, so it's important to review the specific terms and conditions outlined in each property’s details or contact the owner directly for clarification.

4. How do I ensure the vacation rental I choose has the amenities I need?

You can view detailed amenities and property descriptions on the listing page. If you have specific requirements, reaching out to the property owner can help confirm availability before booking.

5. Are there any additional fees I should be aware of when booking a vacation rental here?

Additional fees such as cleaning charges, service fees, or taxes may apply depending on the property. These are typically listed during the booking process or in the property details section.

6. What is the check-in and check-out process for rentals in this region?

Check-in and check-out procedures are specified by each host and can vary. Details are usually provided in the reservation confirmation or upon contacting the property owner directly.

7. Is it possible to find pet-friendly vacation rentals in this destination?

Yes, many listings accommodate pets. You should filter searches for pet-friendly options and verify the owner’s pet policy before completing your reservation.

Best Vacation Homes in Plum Island